• Z1C election rules (Draft 2)

    From Andrew Leary@1:320/219 to All on Wed Apr 25 15:00:25 2018
    Hello everybody!

    === Cut ===
    25-Apr-2018 ZONE 1 COORDINATOR (Z1C) ELECTION RULES

    ============================================

    RULES FOR CONDUCT OF THE Z1C ELECTION, 2018

    * Schedule:

    Apr 30 - May 13 Nominations accepted.
    Discussion begins.
    May 13 - Nominations END at 23:59:59 UTC.
    May 14 - Final list of candidates posted in Z1C.
    Discussion continues.
    May 20 - Discussion ends. Candidates stop campaigning.
    May 21 - Voting begins.
    Jun 3 - Voting ends at 23:59:59 UTC.
    Jun 4 - Results posted in Z1C.
    Jun 4 - Jun 17 Opportunity to yell fowl and fix errors.
    Jun 18 - Final results announced.
    Jun 18 - Jun 21 Turnover from outgoing ZC to winning candidate.
    Jun 22 - New ZC appears in the nodelist and begins work.

    * Position to be Elected:

    The election is for the position of Zone 1 Coordinator (Z1C). The
    responsibilities of the Z1C include but are not limited to:

    -- To compile the nodelists from all of the regions in the zone, and create
    the master nodelist and difference file.

    -- To represent Zone 1 on the Zone Coordinator Council.

    -- See Policy 4 for further details.

    * Voter Eligibility:

    The eligible list is based on the Zone 1 segment of the FidoNet NodeList
    published on Friday, April 27, 2018 (Day 117.)

    Each sysop has one vote, regardless of how many nodes s/he operates.

    Nodes with more than one sysop get only one vote.

    Nodes marked 'Down' are not eligible to vote.

    * Nominations, Candidates:

    Nominations will be placed in the Z1C echo conference. To be
    a candidate, a FidoNet sysop must be seconded by another FidoNet
    sysop. An individual may not nominate himself or second himself.
    Nominations, seconds, and acceptances MUST be confirmed via netmail
    to the votecounter at <address> BEFORE the close of the nomination
    period.

    * Election:

    At the close of balloting, the vote counter will verify the results,
    and a summary of the results will be posted in Z1C.

    The vote counter will not disclose any node's vote to any other node.

    In the event only there is only one candidate properly nominated
    s/he will become the new Zone 1 Coordinator, effective May 18, 2018.

    * Comments by the Candidates:

    Comments by Z1C candidates are to be posted in Z1C no later than
    23:59:59 UTC on May 20. After that, they must STOP campaigning in Z1C
    until the voting period ends. All discussion will take place in
    Z1C.

    * Who Wins?

    The winner will be determined as the candidate receiving more than half
    of the number of valid votes, otherwise known as a majority.

    * Challenges, Election Results:

    The results may be challenged by sending netmail to the Enforcer at
    <address>. It must be received before 23:59:59 UTC on Jun 17, 2018. No
    complaints or contested votes will be considered if received late.

    If the election is declared invalid, a new election shall begin as
    soon as possible, within 14 days of the previous election being declared
    invalid.

    * How to SEND your vote:

    ALL BALLOTS MUST BE NETMAIL ADDRESSED TO 'Enforcer' at <address>.

    You can route your ballot if you choose, but if you value your privacy
    and want to ensure arrival, you should send it directly to <address>.
    Return receipts will be sent via direct or routed netmail. Those return
    receipts will contain NO information except that a vote was received from
    your node.

    * HOW TO VOTE:

    - Write a a NETMail message addressed to 'Enforcer' at <address>.

    - Subject line doesn't matter.

    - Write the name of the valid candidate you want to vote for in the body
    of the message. A final list of valid candidates will be posted on
    May 14 in Z1C. Write-in candidates are not allowed.

    - Make up a password of ten (10) characters or less, and put that in the
    body of the message too.

    NOTE: Your password will be displayed (case insensitive) with your
    choice in Z1C so you can know that your ballot was counted correctly.
    In addition, votes received that do not meet ALL of the above conditions
    will not be counted until corrected by the voter.

    * SAMPLE BALLOT:

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    | Date: May 21 2018 11:09 |
    | From: Joe Sysop, 1:320/999 |
    | To: Enforcer, <address> |
    | Subj: My vote |
    | -------------------------------------------- |
    | <Candidate's Name> |
    | |
    | My password is Hoochie |
    | |
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    When your vote is received, it will NOT be machine-processed. Don't poll
    to pick up a receipt. The Enforcer will send a direct or routed netmail
    receipt to you confirming that he received a ballot but there will be no
    other information in the receipt.

    To ensure that your vote was counted properly, you may check the periodic
    posting of passwords/candidates in Z1C.

    * That's it. Enjoy the election!
    === Cut ===

    Corrected the echo for the public posting of received votes/passwords. If we wish to use Z1_ELECTION for this process, I can change that prior to the final publication. Now we need to select an Enforcer for the election.

    Andrew

    --- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20170303
    * Origin: Phoenix BBS * phoenix.bnbbbs.net (1:320/219)
  • From mark lewis@1:3634/12.73 to Andrew Leary on Thu Apr 26 10:13:26 2018

    On 2018 Apr 25 15:00:24, you wrote to All:

    Hello everybody!

    === Cut ===
    25-Apr-2018 ZONE 1 COORDINATOR (Z1C) ELECTION RULES

    ============================================

    RULES FOR CONDUCT OF THE Z1C ELECTION, 2018

    * Schedule:

    Apr 30 - May 13 Nominations accepted.

    that's only four days away... let's not push this too fast, ok?


    * Nominations, Candidates:

    Nominations will be placed in the Z1C echo conference. To be
    a candidate, a FidoNet sysop must be seconded by another FidoNet
    sysop. An individual may not nominate himself or second himself.
    Nominations, seconds, and acceptances MUST be confirmed via netmail
    to the votecounter at <address> BEFORE the close of the nomination
    period.

    nothing is said here about who may be nominated...

    * Election:

    At the close of balloting, the vote counter will verify the results,
    and a summary of the results will be posted in Z1C.

    there's nothing in this section concerning a validator... i mean a second counter that will verify/validate the count is accurate...

    The vote counter will not disclose any node's vote to any other
    node.

    except to the verifier...

    In the event only there is only one candidate properly nominated
    s/he will become the new Zone 1 Coordinator, effective May 18, 2018.

    * Comments by the Candidates:

    Comments by Z1C candidates are to be posted in Z1C no later than
    23:59:59 UTC on May 20. After that, they must STOP campaigning in Z1C
    until the voting period ends. All discussion will take place in
    Z1C.

    * Who Wins?

    The winner will be determined as the candidate receiving more than
    half
    of the number of valid votes, otherwise known as a majority.

    "absolute majority" as stated by policy4.07, section 6.2... there are too many "majority" options to choose from so let's use the one already specified...

    * How to SEND your vote:

    ALL BALLOTS MUST BE NETMAIL ADDRESSED TO 'Enforcer' at <address>.

    shouldn't this "enforcer" be named above instead of or in addition to "vote counter"?

    )\/(ark

    Always Mount a Scratch Monkey
    Do you manage your own servers? If you are not running an IDS/IPS yer doin' it wrong...
    ... Have you looked on the inter-web?
    ---
    * Origin: (1:3634/12.73)
  • From Andrew Leary@1:320/219 to mark lewis on Thu Apr 26 14:47:34 2018
    Hello mark!

    26 Apr 18 10:13, you wrote to me:

    @REPLY: 1:320/219@fidonet 5ae0d0fa
    @MSGID: 1:3634/12.73 5ae1e074
    @PID: GED+LNX 1.1.5-b20150715
    @CHRS: CP437 2
    @TZUTC: -0400
    @TID: hpt/lnx 1.9.0-cur 07-09-15

    On 2018 Apr 25 15:00:24, you wrote to All:

    Hello everybody!

    === Cut ===
    25-Apr-2018 ZONE 1 COORDINATOR (Z1C) ELECTION RULES

    ============================================

    RULES FOR CONDUCT OF THE Z1C ELECTION, 2018

    * Schedule:

    Apr 30 - May 13 Nominations accepted.

    that's only four days away... let's not push this too fast, ok?

    I fully expect that the timetable will be pushed back, since we haven't selected an election enforcer yet.

    * Nominations, Candidates:

    Nominations will be placed in the Z1C echo conference. To be
    a candidate, a FidoNet sysop must be seconded by another
    FidoNet
    sysop. An individual may not nominate himself or second
    himself.
    Nominations, seconds, and acceptances MUST be confirmed via
    netmail
    to the votecounter at <address> BEFORE the close of the
    nomination
    period.

    nothing is said here about who may be nominated...

    I have no problem with specifying that candidates must have current or previous *C experience.

    * Election:

    At the close of balloting, the vote counter will verify the
    results,
    and a summary of the results will be posted in Z1C.

    there's nothing in this section concerning a validator... i mean a
    second counter that will verify/validate the count is accurate...

    We can add that if the group feels it appropriate. Every sysop will have the ability to verify their ballot is received and counted properly from the periodic postings of votes and passwords.

    The vote counter will not disclose any node's vote to any
    other node.

    except to the verifier...

    Yes, if we decide to use one then they obviously would receive that information.

    In the event only there is only one candidate properly
    nominated
    s/he will become the new Zone 1 Coordinator, effective May
    18, 2018.

    * Comments by the Candidates:

    Comments by Z1C candidates are to be posted in Z1C no later
    than
    23:59:59 UTC on May 20. After that, they must STOP
    campaigning in Z1C
    until the voting period ends. All discussion will take place
    in
    Z1C.

    * Who Wins?

    The winner will be determined as the candidate receiving more
    than half
    of the number of valid votes, otherwise known as a majority.

    "absolute majority" as stated by policy4.07, section 6.2... there are
    too many "majority" options to choose from so let's use the one
    already specified...

    Good point. I have no problem with that either.

    * How to SEND your vote:

    ALL BALLOTS MUST BE NETMAIL ADDRESSED TO 'Enforcer' at
    <address>.

    shouldn't this "enforcer" be named above instead of or in addition to "vote counter"?

    They will be, once we select one (or two if we go with a verifier as well.)

    Andrew

    --- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20170303
    * Origin: Phoenix BBS * phoenix.bnbbbs.net (1:320/219)