• Digital vs Analog

    From Richard Webb@1:116/901 to Ross Sauer on Sat Jun 26 15:51:59 2010
    Hello Ross,

    On Fri 2038-Jun-25 07:19, Ross Sauer (1:123/789) wrote to Richard Webb:

    <snip>

    Out of all my relatives, only one has a digital antenna.
    The rest have satellite or cable.

    AS noted by DAve erlier this thread, and by me many times
    over the last few years, there is no such thing as a
    "digital antenna."
    An antenna is an antenna, is an antenna. THe wavelength of
    the frequency to be transmitted or received is what's important to the antenna.
    LIke woofers emit low frequency sounds, tweeters
    high. An antenna is an antenna is an antenna.

    DIgital antenna is just marketing hype bs to catch the
    unwary.
    WHether the modulation scheme is digital, am, fm, companded
    sideband, single sideband, etc. makes no difference to the
    antenna. Wavelength is the main factor to be considered in
    the design of an antenna, and the desired directional
    characteristics, of course.


    Her antenna looks much like a analog antenna.

    OF course it does, see above. IF it was marketed as a
    "digital" antenna no doubt she paid a premium price for it,
    because the marketing hype was involved.
    IF you had a uhf tv antenna before then you have a "digital" antenna now. DOn't let the sales droid snooker you out of
    any more money. THat is, unless you really need to improve
    your uhf reception, in which case a better antenna is what
    you need.



    Regards,
    Richard
    ... Creationism is to science what storks are to obstetrics.
    --- timEd 1.10.y2k+
    * Origin: (1:116/901)
  • From Michiel van der Vlist@2:280/5555 to Richard Webb on Sat Jun 26 23:35:30 2010
    Hello Richard,

    On Saturday June 26 2010 15:51, you wrote to Ross Sauer:

    AS noted by DAve erlier this thread, and by me many times over the
    last few years, there is no such thing as a "digital antenna."
    An antenna is an antenna, is an antenna.

    We had a similar hype in the sixties when colour TV was introduced here in The Netherlands. TV antennes were advertised as "colour TV antennas".

    Same nonsense. As you say, an antenna is an antenna.

    73 de PA0MMV

    Cheers, Michiel

    --- GoldED+/W32-MINGW 1.1.5-b20070503
    * Origin: http://www.vlist.eu (2:280/5555)
  • From Richard Webb@1:116/901 to Michiel van der Vlist on Sun Jun 27 01:38:48 2010
    Hello Michiel,

    On Sat 2038-Jun-26 23:35, Michiel van der Vlist (2:280/5555) wrote to Richard Webb:

    AS noted by DAve erlier this thread, and by me many times over the
    last few years, there is no such thing as a "digital antenna."
    An antenna is an antenna, is an antenna.

    MvdV> We had a similar hype in the sixties when colour TV was introduced
    MvdV> here in The Netherlands. TV antennes were advertised as "colour TV
    MvdV> antennas".

    YEp, all about separating the unwary and gullible from their money.

    overdosing on field day this weekend in fact.

    73 de nf5b


    Regards,
    Richard
    --- timEd 1.10.y2k+
    * Origin: (1:116/901)